Do I need a CFO or a financial controller?
Somewhere between 15 and 50 staff, most owners in Brisbane and across Queensland hit the same wall. The bookkeeper is flat out, the accountant is someone you see at tax time, and the owner is doing the finance thinking at 9pm. The natural next step looks like a hire, and the two job titles that come up are financial controller and CFO.
They are different jobs. Hiring the wrong one is expensive, and hiring either one full-time is often the wrong answer for a business this size. Here is how to tell which gap you have.
What a financial controller does
A controller runs the finance function. Day to day that means:
- closing the month on time, with every bank account and balance-sheet line reconciled
- overseeing payroll, BAS preparation and the compliance calendar
- managing the bookkeeper or the small finance team
- keeping the chart of accounts, job costing and approvals tidy enough that the numbers can be trusted
- producing the monthly management accounts
The controller’s question is “are the numbers right, and are they on time?” That is a real job. In a business with high transaction volume, several bank accounts, a big payroll or a job-costing system that needs feeding every day, it can be a full-time one.
What a CFO does
A CFO takes numbers that are already right and decides what to do with them. In a business your size, that looks like:
- a cash forecast for the next quarter, rebuilt every month, so a crunch shows up weeks before it hits the bank
- which jobs, clients or products make money once the real costs are loaded
- whether you can afford the next hire, and what it does to runway
- what a price rise, faster collections or an overhead cut is worth in your own dollars
- whether last month’s advice worked, checked against what the books did
The CFO’s question is “what should we do next, and how will we know it worked?” It needs a few days of senior thinking a month. It rarely needs forty hours a week.
Which gap do you have?
Ask two questions.
Are your numbers late or wrong? If the month takes three weeks to close, the bank reconciliations drift, payroll causes a scramble or nobody trusts the job costing, your gap is in running the function. Fix that first. A strong bookkeeper with clear month-end deadlines often solves it. A controller solves it when the volume is too big for one bookkeeper.
Are your numbers fine but nobody is using them? If the books are clean but decisions get made against the bank balance, if you can’t say what next quarter’s cash looks like, or if the same margin problem comes up every month and nothing changes, your gap is the decision layer. That is CFO work.
Most growing businesses we see have the second gap. The bookkeeping is decent. What is missing is someone senior reading it every month and saying what to do.
The option most owners never price
The usual framing is a choice between two salaries. There is a third option, and for most businesses between 15 and 50 staff it costs less than either: keep a strong bookkeeper running the books, and bring in a strategic CFO on a fixed fee for the decision layer.
Here is what that costs with us, in full:
- Reporting, $1,800 a month. A signed monthly board pack built from your own books: cash forecast, goals, margin by line, what each lever is worth, and a written record of every decision and whether it worked. $21,600 a year.
- Advisory, $3,000 a month. Everything in Reporting plus an hour each month walking through the pack and deciding what to do about it. $36,000 a year.
- Quarterly Reporting, $6,000 a quarter. The same depth on a quarterly rhythm. $24,000 a year.
Set that against a full-time hire. Whatever the salary, it comes with 12% super on top, leave, recruitment fees, a desk and the time it takes to find the right person. It is also a fixed cost in a quiet month. A part-time CFO costs the same every month, can move between tiers as the business changes, and does not need managing.
There are honest limits. We do not do your bookkeeping, lodge your BAS or give tax advice; your bookkeeper and accountant keep those jobs. We need clean books to work from, so if your gap is the first one, fix that before you hire us. And we are not a substitute for a full-time CFO when the work truly is full-time.
When the full-time CFO is right
Hire a full-time CFO when the finance work is a job in its own right every week:
- you are raising equity or significant debt, and lenders or investors want a finance lead in the room
- you are preparing for a sale, a merger or an acquisition
- you run several entities that need consolidating and intercompany accounting every month
- you report to an outside board or investors monthly and they expect a CFO to present
If none of those is true, a full-time CFO in a 30-person business usually ends up doing the controller’s work, because that is what fills the week.
Questions to ask before you hire either
- Write down the five decisions you made last quarter that the numbers should have informed. Did they?
- How many days after month-end are your books closed and reconciled?
- Is the problem that the numbers are wrong, or that nobody reads them?
- What would the role do in a quiet month?
- Who will sign the numbers, and what does that signature cover?
If the honest answers point at the decision layer, start by putting someone senior on the numbers you already have. It costs a fraction of a salary, and you will know within a quarter whether it is enough.
Fahy Advisory is a strategic CFO service for SME owners in Brisbane, Queensland and across Australia. Most people search for it as an outsourced or part-time CFO. We work alongside your existing bookkeeper and accountant, never in place of them. See what it costs, how it works, or book a discovery call, no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a CFO and a financial controller?
A financial controller runs the finance function: the month-end close, reconciliations, payroll and BAS oversight, the compliance calendar and the team that does the books. A CFO uses the numbers to decide: cash and runway, pricing and margin, whether to hire, which work to chase, how to fund growth. The controller makes sure the numbers are right and on time. The CFO decides what to do about them.
Should a 30-person business hire a CFO or a financial controller first?
Usually neither as a full-time hire. At 20 to 50 staff most businesses need the books run well and someone senior turning them into decisions each month. A strong bookkeeper, or a controller if the transaction volume really demands one, covers the first. A strategic CFO on a fixed monthly fee covers the second, for less than either salary.
When does a business need a full-time CFO?
When the finance work is a full-time job in its own right: raising capital or debt, preparing for a sale or acquisition, consolidating several entities, or reporting to an outside board or investors every month. Below that, a full-time CFO tends to spend much of the week doing controller work.
How much does an outsourced CFO cost compared with hiring one?
Ours is a fixed fee: $1,800 a month for the signed monthly board pack (Reporting), $3,000 a month with a monthly review call (Advisory), or $6,000 a quarter for the quarterly cadence. That is $21,600 to $36,000 a year. A full-time hire carries a salary plus 12% super, leave, recruitment and a desk, and it is a fixed cost whether or not there is a big decision that month.
See the decision layer in action.
Book a 20-minute discovery call, or download a sample board pack. There's no pressure either way.